Hiring Playbook

What is direct recruiting in Japan? How it differs from scouting, and what it costs

What direct recruiting means in Japan, how it differs from scouting and recruitment agencies, what it costs, how it works for new graduates, and the legal rules for sending scouts.

Illustration: a company picks one profile from a candidate database and sends it a scout
Emmanuel Gendre Former Google recruiter, HR and hiring advisor to SMBs Last updated 24 min read

Basics

What is direct recruiting? The company finds candidates itself and sends them scout messages

In short

Direct recruiting means a company searches candidate databases or social media itself and sends scout messages to the people it wants to hire. Unlike job ads, which wait for applicants, and recruitment agencies, which pick candidates for you, the company itself chooses the candidate and makes the first contact.

This approach, where the company finds and contacts candidates itself, is also called scout hiring or direct sourcing. BizReach describes the service it launched in 2009 as "Japan's first full-scale direct recruiting tool" (company announcement, February 5, 2016).

There are four main places to find candidates.

Main channels for direct recruiting
ChannelWhere you find candidatesCost
Scout platformsCandidate databases on job and graduate sitesPlatform fees
Social mediaPublic profiles such as LinkedInStaff time (paid features extra)
Events and meetupsYour own meetups and industry eventsEvent costs and staff time
Talent poolPast applicants and former employeesStaff time

Referral hiring, where employees introduce people they know, puts an employee between the company and the candidate, so this guide treats it as a separate method.

Comparison

Direct recruiting vs scouting, job ads and agencies: who contacts the candidate

The difference is who chooses the candidate and makes the first contact. In direct recruiting the company chooses; with job ads the candidate chooses the company and applies; with a recruitment agency, the agency chooses candidates and introduces them to you.

How direct recruiting, job ads and recruitment agencies differ
ItemDirect recruitingJob adsRecruitment agency
Who picks the candidateThe companyThe candidateThe agency
Who you reachIncludes people not lookingPeople who are lookingThe agency's registrants
CostFixed fee or success feePosting feeSuccess fee
Legal statusRecruitment of workersRecruitment of workersJob placement (licensed)

Legal status under Articles 4 and 30 of the Employment Security Act.

A "scout" is the message sent to a candidate; direct recruiting is the whole method: the company itself searches for candidates, chooses them, contacts them and meets them. Some explain the difference as bulk sends (scouting) versus one-to-one messages (direct recruiting), but legally, what matters is who sends the message, not how it is sent. On some scout platforms, agencies can send scouts as well as companies: more than 9,500 headhunters are registered on BizReach (end of July 2026), and Recruit Direct Scout describes itself as "a service where hiring companies or recruitment agents send scouts" (both on their official sites). A scout from the company is recruitment; a scout from an agency is job placement.

Headhunting: an agency approaches candidates for you

In headhunting, a recruitment agency searches for candidates and approaches them for you, including people who are not looking for a job, and encourages them to change jobs. It then introduces those who are interested to your company. The difference from direct recruiting is who makes the contact: the agency, not your company. You pay the agency a fee when you hire; the costs section compares it with direct recruiting.

Statistics

Who direct recruiting reaches: 6.63 million people want to change jobs but are not looking

In Japan's Labour Force Survey, 10.23 million employed people wanted to change or add a job in 2025, and 6.63 million of them were not looking for work. That year, 3.3 million people changed jobs. Job ads and recruitment agencies mainly reach people who are looking. Direct recruiting is how a company reaches the people who are not.

People who want to change jobs (2025)

Statistics Bureau, Labour Force Survey (Detailed Tabulation)

Not looking for work
65%
6.63M
Looking for work
35%
3.60M

Shares are our calculation from the published figures.

The 10.23 million includes people who want a second job alongside their current one, so not all 6.63 million want to leave their employer. It still shows how many people a job ad is unlikely to reach. Labour is also short: the job openings-to-applicants ratio averaged 1.22 in 2025 and stood at 1.19 in September 2026, and 1.01 for regular employees (MHLW, Employment Referrals for General Workers).

37.3% of companies use it, but only 15.1% of those with 3 to 50 staff

In Mynavi's Mid-Career Hiring Survey 2026 (1,500 companies), 37.3% used direct recruiting in 2025, up every year from 26.9% in 2021. Company size matters: 15.1% of companies with 3 to 50 staff used it, against 50.2% of those with 1,001 or more. The channel most used by companies with 3 to 50 staff was Hello Work, the public employment service (43.3%).

Companies using direct recruiting (mid-career)

  1. 2021: 26.9%
  2. 2022: 34.1%
  3. 2023: 35.1%
  4. 2024: 36.5%
  5. 2025: 37.3%+0.8 points on 2024

Share of companies. Source: Mynavi Mid-Career Hiring Survey 2026

Use by company size (2025)

  1. 3–50 staff15.1%
  2. 51–300 staff29.9%
  3. 301–1,000 staff45.0%
  4. 1,001+ staff50.2%

Share of companies using direct recruiting for mid-career hiring. Source: Mynavi

Japan's official statistics do not count people hired through scouts. The Survey on Employment Trends has no "scout" category for hiring routes, and job sites fall under "advertising". In the same survey, of mid-career hires at companies with 5 to 29 staff, 38.6% came through personal connections, 22.5% through ads and 18.7% through Hello Work (including its online service); only 3.3% came through private placement agencies (2025, our calculation). So a small company weighing direct recruiting should compare it with personal connections such as referral hiring, job ads and Hello Work, rather than with agencies.

Costs

What direct recruiting costs: ¥1.74 million a year on average

In Mynavi's survey, companies that used direct recruiting spent an average of ¥1.74 million on it in 2025: ¥588,000 less than the year before, and less than half the ¥3.76 million that agency users spent on recruitment agencies. The average is pulled up by heavy users: 48.1% of users spent under ¥500,000.

Yearly spend by hiring channel (mid-career)

  1. Recruitment agencies¥3.76M
  2. Direct recruiting¥1.74M
  3. Job ads¥1.25M

Average per company that used the channel (2025). Source: Mynavi Mid-Career Hiring Survey 2026

Trends in hiring costs by channel and ad costs by job type are in our cost per hire guide.

Platform pricing compared: the cost of one hire

Pricing comes in three models and combinations of them: a success fee as a share of salary, a fixed success fee per hire, and a fixed fee covering a period or a set number of hires. Most platforms only share their price list on request, so we calculated the cost of one hire from official sites, financial filings and published reseller information, and ranked them from highest to lowest. For mid-career, we priced one hire at a theoretical annual salary (expected yearly pay, excluding overtime) of ¥5 million, on the cheapest plan that lets you send scouts.

Cost of one hire (highest first)

  • Share of salary
  • Fixed fee per hire
  • Fixed fee per period

Mid-careerone hire at a theoretical annual salary of ¥5 million

  • GreenAtraeSetup fee + share of salary¥1.6M–¥1.8MSetup ¥600k + 20% of salary from Jan 2027
  • BizReachBizReach, Inc.Period fee + share of salary¥1.6M¥850k for 6 months + 15% of salary
  • MIIDASMIIDAS Co., Ltd.Fixed fee for 1 year¥1.6M+1 year, any number of hires
  • Agency (reference)Placement agency feeShare of salary¥1.5MAbout 30% of salary (Mynavi survey)
  • WantedlyWantedly, Inc.Fixed fee per period¥900k6 months, 150 scouts
  • doda DirectPERSOL CAREERFixed fee per period¥800k8 weeks, no success fee
  • En Tenshoku Directen Inc.Fixed fee per period¥800k12 weeks, no success fee
  • Recruit Direct ScoutIndeed Recruit PartnersShare of salary¥750k15% of theoretical salary, on hire only

New graduatesone hire

  • LabBaseLabBase Inc.Fixed fee per year¥1.2M+1 year, no success fee
  • OfferBoxi-plug, Inc.Fixed fee per hire¥450kSuccess fee, no setup fee
  • doda CampusBenesse i-CareerFixed fee per hire¥350kSuccess fee, no setup fee

Calculated from official sites, financial filings and reseller information (November 5, 2026, excluding tax).

BizReach: its operator's annual securities report (October 2026). MIIDAS: the standard price on a Tokyo Chamber of Commerce and Industry member-services page. Green, Wantedly and doda Direct plan prices, and LabBase: published reseller information. Other platforms: their official sites. Agency: about 30% of salary, as stated in Mynavi's survey.

For a single mid-career hire, Recruit Direct Scout, which charges only a success fee (¥750,000), is the cheapest, and BizReach and MIIDAS (¥1.6 million) cost more than paying an agency about 30% of salary (¥1.5 million). Fixed-fee plans cost the same however many people you hire during the period, so the cost per hire falls from the second hire. The periods are 8 weeks for doda Direct, 12 weeks for En Tenshoku Direct, 6 months for Wantedly and 1 year for MIIDAS.

Fees based on a share of salary rise with the salary of the person hired: above a theoretical salary of ¥5.33 million, Recruit Direct Scout costs more than the ¥800,000 fixed plans. Green's success fee depends on the job type today: ¥1.2 million for engineers and executives, ¥900,000 for sales and planning, and ¥600,000 for administrative and service roles. For people who apply from 12 January 2027, it becomes 20% of the salary, with those amounts as a minimum and a cap of ¥2 million. Agency fees averaged about ¥1.03 million per permanent placement in MHLW's figures (Placement Business Reports, FY2024).

Whatever the model, the time your staff spend searching and writing scouts is not in the fee.

Our cost per hire calculator adds staff time to the fees: enter the hires you made through scouts to compare your cost per hire across channels.

Avoid being billed twice for one hire

The Kagoshima Labour Bureau warns that more employers are being billed success fees by several services for the same hire, or even for people they hired through Hello Work. When you hire someone, record the route they applied through. Since April 2025, recruitment information services such as scout platforms must state their fees and penalties in advance (MHLW). Before signing, check whether you pay if someone you scouted applies through another route.

Decision

Pros and cons of direct recruiting: wider reach, but the work stays with you

The pros are reaching people who are not looking and spending less than on agencies. The con is that the work of searching, writing and replying stays with you.

Pros and cons of direct recruiting, with figures and sources
PointFigureSource
Pros
Reaches people who are not looking6.63MStatistics Bureau 2025
Yearly cost under half that of agencies¥1.74MMynavi 2025
Hire rate on par with other channels62.7%Mynavi 2025
High satisfaction among users84.3%Mynavi 2025
Cons
Few replies to scouts0.7%Nikkei job board, Sep 2026
Finding candidates takes time61.7%Leverages 2023
Fewer hires per company3.65Mynavi 2025

The hire rate is the share of companies using a channel that made a hire through it. Satisfaction is from the 140 companies whose main channel was direct recruiting.

The hire rate is close to that of agencies (66.0%) and job sites (63.3%). The difference is volume: companies made 3.65 hires on average through direct recruiting, against 5.40 through agencies (Mynavi). The cost row compares each company's yearly spend, not the cost of filling the same job.

Which companies it suits, and which it does not

It suits companies that hire a few experienced people and can state pay and other terms up front. Reply rates are higher among people in their 40s and 50s (how to start), and working conditions must in principle be stated by the first contact (the law).

Who direct recruiting suits

Good fit

Few hires, chosen for experience

  • The people you want already work elsewhere
  • You can state the pay range in the first message
  • Someone can spend time on scouting every week
  • You hire a few people a year

Poor fit

Combine it with other channels

  • You hire many people for the same job at once
  • You cannot state pay or location up front
  • No one has time to write scouts

Rules

The law on sending scouts: state the working conditions by the first contact

A scout sent by a company is "recruitment of workers", so the recruitment rules of the Employment Security Act and other laws apply in full. There are four things to observe: stating working conditions, not misrepresenting anything, handling personal data only for its purpose, and not restricting candidates by age or sex.

Article 5-3 of the Employment Security Act requires employers who recruit to state working conditions such as duties, pay and working hours. On timing, MHLW's Guidelines say "in principle, by the time of first contact with the job seeker". "First contact" is when an exchange begins, by interview, email or phone; messages to schedule an interview do not count (Recruitment and Job Offer Handling Manual). If the scout itself or an attached job posting states the main terms, the candidate sees them before replying. You may state them by email or a social media message only if the candidate asks for that; otherwise, give them in writing (Enforcement Regulations of the Employment Security Act, Article 4-2). Since April 2024, the scope of change for duties and workplace, and any cap on renewing fixed-term contracts, must also be stated. Keep a record of what you stated until recruitment ends (or until the contract date, if later).

Article 5-4 prohibits false or misleading job information. The Guidelines name showing pay as higher than it really is and using job titles far from the actual work. The rule covers email and social media messages, not just job ads. Recruiting with false conditions can be punished by up to six months' imprisonment or a fine of up to ¥300,000 (Article 65). When you fill the role, stop or correct any scouts and ads still running, and show the date each job posting was last updated.

Collect candidates' personal data only as far as a stated purpose requires (Article 5-5). "Used for hiring" is not specific enough; state it like "used to contact you about interview dates". Do not collect permanent domicile or birthplace, beliefs, or union membership. Collecting information the person has made public, for example on social media, is one of the lawful and fair methods the Guidelines list.

Recruitment and hiring must give equal opportunity regardless of age or sex (Act on Comprehensive Promotion of Labor Policies, Article 9; Equal Employment Opportunity Act, Article 5). You may put an age cap in a scout or job posting only under the exceptions the law allows.

Pre-send scout checklist

Before you send a scout, go through the message and the attached job posting from top to bottom. You can save the ticked list as a PDF and print it for internal checks.

Direct recruiting

Pre-send scout checklist

0 / 11 done

Checks based on Articles 5-3 to 5-5 of the Employment Security Act, Article 4-2 of its Enforcement Regulations, the MHLW Guidelines under the Act, Article 9 of the Act on Comprehensive Promotion of Labor Policies and Article 5 of the Equal Employment Opportunity Act.

If you outsource scouting, check the licence or registration

If your own staff send scouts, no licence is needed. If you pay outsiders to send them, they need a permit; if a platform chooses candidates or rewrites messages for each candidate, it needs a job placement licence (see the table). In September 2026, MHLW added scout examples to its Operating Manual for Recruitment Information Providers and stated that choosing candidates or editing messages automatically with AI also counts as job placement.

Legal status when you outsource scouting
ActionLegal statusBasis
The platform sends your template to candidates you choseRecruitment information serviceManual example 4-3
The platform picks and recommends candidatesJob placementManual example 1-3
The platform adds a pay estimate for each candidateJob placementManual example 4-4
The platform interviews for you and passes on an assessmentJob placementManual examples 4-6 to 4-8
Paying an outside firm to send scouts for youOutsourced recruitmentEmployment Security Act, Art. 36

Manual = MHLW Operating Manual for Recruitment Information Providers (September 2026). Job placement needs a licence and outsourced recruitment a permit, both from the Minister of Health, Labour and Welfare.

You can check whether a platform or outsourcing firm holds a job placement licence or is registered as a recruitment information provider on MHLW's Human Resources Services website, which also shows any administrative actions against registered providers.

Steps

How to start direct recruiting: 6 steps

Before you start, decide who to hire, at what pay, and who will send the scouts.

Then follow these six steps.

  1. Decide who to hire and on what terms

    Set the duties, the required experience and the pay range, and put them in a job posting. Your scouts will lead with these terms.

  2. Choose a platform

    Check that the people you want are registered there (mid-career or graduate, role, age), how pricing works, and the platform's licence or registration. Before you sign, ask to see how many profiles match your criteria in the search screen.

  3. Search widely

    Do not narrow the criteria too early; list everyone who could fit. The hiring process guide explains how to build the list.

  4. Send the scouts

    Say why you are writing to this person and what makes the job attractive, give the pay range, and propose a short call. Before sending, check the terms against the checklist.

  5. Reply fast and set up a call

    Make the first call an exchange of information rather than a selection step, and start selection once the candidate decides to apply.

  6. Track the numbers

    Log sends, opens, replies, calls and hires each week, and compare different messages and targets. When someone is hired, record the route they came through too.

Reply rates to expect: 0.7% across a large job board

Data published by Nikkei's job board shows that in September 2026, 10.5% of scouts were opened and 0.7% got a reply, about 143 scouts per reply. By age, the reply rate was 0.3% for those under 30, 0.4% in their 30s, 1.1% in their 40s and 3.3% in their 50s, rising with age (16.2% at 60 and over). Premium scouts (Gold Scouts) had a 2.9% reply rate.

Scout reply rate by age (September 2026)

  1. All0.7%
  2. Under 300.3%
  3. 30s0.4%
  4. 40s1.1%
  5. 50s3.3%

Excludes some bulk sends. Source: Nikkei job board site report

You may see reply rates above 20% quoted, but that is a figure one engineering-focused service published for scouts sent in the morning, excluding the heaviest and lightest senders. In a survey of 123 recruiters using direct recruiting (Leverages, 2023), 55.0% said reply rates were poor and 61.7% said finding candidates took too long. Allow for these low reply rates when you plan your time to hire.

New graduates

Direct recruiting for new graduates: student data only from March 1

For new graduates, there are also reverse-search (offer-type) platforms where companies approach students based on their profiles. But under the government's request, students' personal data may not be used for publicity or selection before publicity starts on March 1.

Recruiting schedule for students graduating in March 2027 and March 2028
ActivityGraduating March 2027Graduating March 2028
Publicity startsFrom March 1, 2026From March 1, 2027
Selection startsFrom June 1, 2026From June 1, 2027
Formal job offers (naitei)From October 1, 2026From October 1, 2027

Based on the request of the Cabinet Secretariat's liaison meeting on graduate recruitment schedules.

Opening student registration on your own careers site or a job site counts as publicity, so it waits until March 1. Before that, keep to general information for an unspecified audience, and do not collect or use students' personal data. Student data from qualifying (Type 3) internships can be used from March for publicity and from June for selection. Students who show advanced skills in a specialist internship of two weeks or more can move to selection before June (Cabinet Secretariat). The request is not legally binding, and the schedule for students graduating in March 2029 and later is under review. Offer dates are covered in our nainaitei guide.

In Mynavi's survey, 8.4% of companies used reverse-search hiring for the class of 2027, and 6.5% of those with fewer than 300 staff. In DISCO's student surveys, 12.8% used reverse-search platforms to discover companies (March), and 4.4% first learned about the company they would join through a scout service (July). For new graduates, scouting supplements job sites.

Companies recruiting new graduates must provide youth employment information, such as hiring and turnover figures, training and retention measures, when applicants ask (Youth Employment Promotion Act, Article 13). Students you scout may well ask, so include it in the job posting.

FAQ

Direct recruiting FAQ

What does direct recruiting mean?

It means the company finds candidates itself and contacts them directly. The company searches candidate databases or social media and sends scout messages; in Japan, the English term is used as a loanword. How it works is explained in "What is direct recruiting?".

What is direct sourcing?

Largely the same as direct recruiting. The term stresses that the company does the sourcing (finding candidates) itself. Our time to hire calculator uses "direct sourcing" for hiring that starts with a reply to a scout.

Should we avoid recruitment agencies?

No. Among companies that used them, 66.0% made a hire, the highest rate of the main channels (Mynavi). But the fee averages about ¥1.03 million per permanent placement (FY2024), so weigh the cost against the likelihood of hiring. Agencies are licensed by the Minister of Health, Labour and Welfare, and MHLW's Human Resources Services website shows each agency's licence, fee schedule, refund policy and how many placed hires left within six months. Agencies may not encourage someone they placed (in a permanent role) to change jobs for two years.

How do we choose a headhunting firm?

Choose one with a job placement licence. Headhunting is job placement, and licence numbers can be searched on the Human Resources Services website, which also shows fee schedules, refund policies and certification as an excellent placement business. Some platforms, such as BizReach and Recruit Direct Scout, also let headhunters send scouts.

Can we scout people who work for another company?

Yes. Everyone is free to choose their occupation (Employment Security Act, Article 2), and hiring talent is open competition. It can become unlawful when it goes beyond what is socially acceptable, for example colluding with an employee to take a large team in a planned move (Raxon case, Tokyo District Court, February 25, 1991). A company that takes in trade secrets from a hire's former employer, knowing they were taken improperly, can also be liable under the Unfair Competition Prevention Act.

Can we scout on LinkedIn or other social media?

Yes. A company contacting people itself is direct recruitment and needs no licence. Social media messages are treated like email under the rules on stating conditions and on job information. Collecting information the person has made public is one accepted method, but only as far as hiring needs it. Since October 2026, employers must also take measures to prevent sexual harassment of job seekers, including on social media.

Can direct recruiting be free?

Yes, without platform fees. You can search and contact people on social media, or reach out to past applicants and former employees. Contacting past applicants is limited to the purpose of use you gave for their personal data when they applied. Whatever the method, searching and writing takes staff time.

DIY Hiring Kit

Everything You Need To Hire On Your Own

A downloadable hiring framework for small businesses in Japan, with step-by-step guides, spreadsheet ATS, LinkedIn scouting system, interview questions bank, offer letter and employment contracts, and a ton more!

1Dashboard11Checklists8Spreadsheets30Template docs4Weeks of Q&ABilingual

  • Download every file as Word, Google Docs, Excel or Google Sheets

About the author

Emmanuel Gendre, Founder of SaiyouTeam

Emmanuel Gendre

Founder, SaiyouTeam · HR and recruiting advisor to SMBs in Japan

  • Former Google recruiter
  • 14 years in talent acquisition

Emmanuel advises SMBs on HR and recruiting in Japan. Before founding SaiyouTeam, he spent 14 years in talent acquisition, including as a recruiter at Google. This guide is part of that advisory work: it brings together how direct recruiting works, what it costs, and the legal rules for sending scouts.

Official sources

The main sources this guide is based on, most of them in Japanese. Other statistics and documents are linked where they are used.

Important. This page is general information based on laws and published data as of November 5, 2026, not legal advice. Survey figures apply to each survey's sample and date. Platform prices were checked the same day on official sites, financial filings and published reseller information. Shares marked as our calculation are computed from published headcounts.